What is The Best Choice to Make in Skyrim’s “In My Time of Need” Quest?

Ah, fellow Dovahkiin! I remember that chilly evening in Whiterun like it was yesterday. My character, a battle-hardened Nord, had just finished bartering some newly acquired dragon bones when I stumbled upon a scene that would lead me down one of Skyrim’s most morally convoluted rabbit holes: The quest “In My Time of Need.” I felt as if I’d been thrown into one of those old-school “Choose Your Own Adventure” books, but with Daedric stakes. Should I side with the desperate Saadia or the mysterious Alik’r warriors? I swear, it was tougher than deciding whether to join the Imperials or the Stormcloaks! As I delved deeper into the quest, it hit me: wouldn’t others also grapple with this very conundrum?

I imagine you’re here, just like I was, pondering:

  • What’s the gist of this quest?
  • What’s the best decision to make?
  • What are the benefits and pitfalls of siding with Saadia?
  • How about allying with the Alik’r?

You’re not alone in this. Navigating Skyrim can sometimes feel like trying to beat an Elder Dragon with a wooden sword – challenging, overwhelming, and filled with second-guessing. But worry not! This guide is your enchanted map, detailing all the twists, turns, and shouts related to this quest.

So, strap on your Daedric armor and ready your best spell – let’s delve deep into the heart of this dilemma together. Keep reading, and by Talos, you’ll conquer this quest like the Dragonborn you truly are!

“In My Time of Need”: An Introduciton to a Multi-Faceted Quest.

Ah, “In My Time of Need” – that takes me back to my countless hours diving into the world of Skyrim! This quest is one of those intriguing side quests that presents you with a moral choice, and if you’ve played Skyrim, you know there’s no shortage of those. Let me break it down for you.

The story kicks off when you encounter two Alik’r warriors interrogating a Redguard woman in Whiterun. These Redguard folks are basically looking for another Redguard woman named Saadia, who’s on the run. Depending on how you stumble upon this quest, you might meet Saadia herself in The Bannered Mare, a tavern in Whiterun, before the Alik’r men even approach her.

Saadia’s side of the story is that she spoke out against the Aldmeri Dominion back in her homeland of Hammerfell, and now there are assassins out to get her. That sounds bad, right? However, the Alik’r warriors have a different tale. According to them, Saadia betrayed Hammerfell to the Dominion, which is why they’re hunting her down. Quite the plot twist!

This is where you come in. Who do you believe? Do you help Saadia and fend off the Alik’r warriors, or do you believe the Alik’r and help them capture Saadia? The choices are in your hands.

The quest involves some sleuthing around Whiterun, a possible brawl or two with the Alik’r warriors, and ultimately deciding Saadia’s fate. It’s one of those quests that might have you second-guessing your choice even after you’ve completed it.

But that’s the beauty of Skyrim, isn’t it? It throws these moral curveballs at you and lets you choose your path, even if there’s no definitive “right” answer. So, good luck with your decision-making, and may your adventures in Skyrim be ever epic!

What is the best choice to make in the “In My Time of Need” quest in Skyrim?

Ah, the age-old debate among Skyrim players: What is the “best” choice in the “In My Time of Need” quest?

Here’s the thing: The Elder Scrolls series, and Skyrim in particular, is known for its moral ambiguity. The “best” choice often depends on the perspective and morality of the player. However, I’ll lay down the facts and some interpretations so you can make an informed decision:

  1. Helping Saadia:
    • If you believe Saadia’s story, she’s a victim. By helping her, you’re protecting her from alleged assassins.
    • The Alik’r warriors are seen trying to capture or harass a woman in a foreign city, which isn’t exactly honorable.
    • However, if the Alik’r are right, you’re aiding a traitor.
    • From a rewards perspective, Saadia will offer to pay you for your help if you side with her.
  2. Helping the Alik’r:
    • If you believe the Alik’r warriors, Saadia betrayed her city in Hammerfell to the Aldmeri Dominion, which is a severe crime. By capturing her, you’re bringing a traitor to justice.
    • The Alik’r’s warrant for Saadia can be found, which provides some legitimacy to their claims.
    • The Thalmor, closely affiliated with the Aldmeri Dominion, never intervene or comment on Saadia’s case, which might be odd if she were truly a vocal critic.
    • Kematu, the Alik’r leader, chooses to paralyze Saadia rather than kill her outright, suggesting he may be more interested in justice than assassination.
    • From a rewards perspective, the Alik’r will pay you if you help them.

In terms of raw gameplay mechanics, the rewards for either choice are relatively minor and won’t impact your overall gameplay experience significantly. Thus, the decision really comes down to whom you believe or how you envision your character’s moral compass.

Personally? I’ve played it both ways, just to experience both outcomes. It’s one of those quests where the lines between right and wrong are blurred, and that’s part of what makes Skyrim such a captivating game. Whatever you choose, just enjoy the rich storytelling and the journey!

What Are The Pros and Cons of Siding With Saadia?

Ah, the nitty-gritty of making choices in Skyrim! Siding with Saadia in the “In My Time of Need” quest certainly has its own set of pros and cons. Let’s dive in:


  1. Heroic Rescue: If you believe Saadia, you’re essentially saving her from cold-blooded assassins. You get to be the hero of the day.
  2. Immediate Reward: Saadia offers you a financial reward once you’ve dealt with the Alik’r warriors. It’s a quick way to get some extra gold.
  3. Less Complexity: You don’t have to go through the extra steps of capturing Saadia and bringing her to the Alik’r. You confront the Alik’r warriors, take them down, and you’re pretty much done.
  4. Feel-Good Factor: The emotional payoff can feel more immediate and satisfying. Saadia seems genuinely grateful for your help, and it can feel like you’ve made a ‘right’ decision in a world filled with moral gray areas.


  1. Possible Betrayal: If the Alik’r are telling the truth, then Saadia is actually a traitor to her people. In that case, you’ve just aided and abetted a criminal.
  2. Lack of Closure: Unlike with the Alik’r, who claim they want to bring Saadia back for a trial, you never actually find out what happens to Saadia after you help her. The quest doesn’t offer any resolution or additional information to validate your choice.
  3. Limited Interaction: After the quest is completed, Saadia becomes a non-interactive NPC and mostly just exists in the background. Some players find this a bit anti-climactic.
  4. Missed Lore: Siding with the Alik’r offers more context and lore, especially if you’re interested in the geopolitics between Hammerfell and the Aldmeri Dominion. You miss out on this layer of depth if you side with Saadia.
  5. Combat Challenges: The Alik’r you confront can be quite formidable opponents depending on your level and skills. If you’re looking for an easier route, capturing Saadia can be less of a hassle.

So there you have it, the pros and cons of siding with Saadia in a nutshell. Whichever side you choose, remember that the essence of Skyrim lies in making these morally complex choices. That’s what keeps the game interesting, even years after its release!

What Are The Pros and Cons of Siding With The Alik’r?

Let’s break down the decision of siding with the Alik’r in the “In My Time of Need” quest in Skyrim:


  1. Justice Delivered: If you believe the Alik’r’s version, then you’re aiding in bringing a traitor to justice. It gives a sense of closure to the larger geopolitical issue surrounding Hammerfell and the Aldmeri Dominion.
  2. Reward: Kematu, the Alik’r leader, will pay you a sum of gold for your assistance. A straightforward way to earn some coin!
  3. More Lore: By engaging with the Alik’r and listening to their perspective, you get a deeper understanding of the geopolitics in the Elder Scrolls universe, especially the tensions between Hammerfell and the Aldmeri Dominion.
  4. Mercy Over Murder: Kematu uses a paralysis technique on Saadia rather than killing her outright, indicating a potential for justice over simple assassination.
  5. Validity: There’s a warrant for Saadia’s arrest, which gives some legitimacy to the Alik’r’s claims. Also, their presence isn’t totally undercover; they’re allowed in cities like Whiterun, suggesting they might have official sanction.


  1. Possible Betrayal: If Saadia is truthful, then by aiding the Alik’r, you are handing over an innocent woman to be executed, which is a morally challenging situation.
  2. Moral Complexity: The Alik’r are found interrogating women in Whiterun aggressively. This kind of behavior may seem unsavory to some players, making it harder to trust them.
  3. No Concrete Evidence: Despite the Alik’r’s claims, there’s no undeniable evidence presented that Saadia is a traitor, so you’re going off hearsay.
  4. Possible Combat: If you mess up the stealth aspect or decide not to betray Saadia directly, you might have to face Kematu and his warriors, who can be challenging opponents.
  5. A Sense of Guilt: Depending on your personal inclinations or the character’s role-playing direction, you might end up feeling guilty about betraying Saadia, especially given her emotional pleas.

Both choices in this quest present a unique set of moral challenges, making it one of Skyrim’s memorable quests. The decision isn’t black and white, which is part of the beauty of the game. It’s all about how you interpret the situation and how you wish to role-play your character. Enjoy the journey and the storytelling, and remember that every choice adds a layer to your character’s tale!

Final Words and Summary

Ah, Dragonborn, our journey through the winding paths of Whiterun’s dilemmas has been as epic as any ballad sung by the bards in the mead halls. Reflecting upon our adventures, I’m reminded of the weight of the Dragonborn’s decisions, and just how complex the world of Skyrim truly is. As we close this chapter, let’s harken back to the tales told:

  • The mysterious beginnings of the “In My Time of Need” quest.
  • The daunting task of making the “best” decision.
  • The merits and drawbacks of siding with Saadia.
  • The potential gains and losses of aligning with the Alik’r.
  • The immersive lore of Hammerfell and the Aldmeri Dominion.
  • The emotional and moral weight that rests on our Dragonborn shoulders.

As we draw the curtains on this tale, I encourage you to forge onward and delve into our “What Next?” section. The journey never truly ends, after all.

What Next?

I’ve always believed that every great tale should inspire action, guiding you towards your next legendary feat. After all, what’s a Dragonborn without a quest? Here are your next steps:

  • Revisit the quest with a new character, exploring a different moral choice.
  • Engage in forums and discuss your choices with fellow players.
  • Read up on more lore regarding Hammerfell and the Aldmeri Dominion.
  • Write your own take on the quest, maybe a fan-fiction twist?
  • Share your Skyrim adventures with friends, exchanging experiences and decisions.


Nick Sinclair

Nick Sinclair, a gaming aficionado since the Commodore 64 era, studied Creative Computer Games Design in university before founding his own gaming company. Discovering a passion for content creation, Nick now helps gamers squeeze every drop of fun out of their favorite gaming hardware

Recent Posts