Who is the Butcher in Skyrim? You’ll be shocked. I was.

Ah, fellow Dragonborn, gather ’round the campfire and let me regale you with a tale from my adventures in the frosty realm of Skyrim. You know, amidst the shouts, dragon battles, and endless cheese wheels, there was one quest that threw me for a loop more than a Draugr Deathlord’s shout. Ever been to Windhelm? If you have, you might’ve stumbled upon the chilling tale of the Butcher. I remember the first time I set foot in that city, feeling like I’d picked up a quest item without realizing its significance. I mean, who expects a murder mystery in a land where dragons are the main concern?

I found myself pondering:

  • Who exactly is this infamous “Butcher”?
  • Is this questline worth the time and effort?
  • How do I navigate the twists and turns of this detective saga?
  • And most importantly, what are the rewards and pitfalls of solving this mystery?

I bet many of you, my fellow adventurers, have faced the same conundrums. And trust me, in a game as vast as Skyrim, having a guide for such intricate quests is like having a Clairvoyance spell for life. So, if you’ve ever felt lost in the snowy streets of Windhelm, wondering how to catch a killer, you’re in the right place.

Ready to unlock this quest’s secrets? Equip your reading glasses and let’s dive into the lore of “Blood on the Ice.” Keep on reading, and may your path be clear!

The Butcher of Skyrim: An Introduction

Ah, the infamous “Butcher” of Windhelm! If you’ve ever wandered the snowy streets of Windhelm in Skyrim, you might’ve come across some rather unsettling flyers or heard whispers of a mysterious killer on the loose. Let’s dive into this chilling tale, shall we?

So, you’re in Windhelm, probably freezing your toes off, and you start hearing about these gruesome murders. Women are being killed, and the city is in an uproar. The guards seem to be at a loss, and there’s this eerie feeling in the air. You might even stumble upon a crime scene if you’re “lucky” (or perhaps unlucky is the better word).

Enter the “Butcher.” This isn’t some guy who’s really good at chopping up meat for the market. No, this is a sinister figure who’s been leaving a trail of victims in his wake. The city’s residents are terrified, and rumors are flying left and right. Some say it’s a ghost, others think it’s a deranged mage, and a few even believe it’s one of the city’s elite trying to cover up some dark secret.

As you delve deeper into the mystery, you’ll uncover a series of journals, clues, and witnesses that will lead you on a thrilling chase to unmask the true identity of the Butcher. Without giving too much away (because, hey, spoilers aren’t cool), let’s just say that the truth behind the Butcher is both shocking and deeply rooted in Skyrim’s rich lore.

So, if you’re ever in Windhelm and fancy yourself a bit of a detective, why not try your hand at solving the mystery of the Butcher? Just… maybe keep a weapon handy. You never know who you might run into in those shadowy alleys. ?

Is the Butcher part of a Skyrim Quest?

The Butcher’s sinister deeds are central to a quest in Windhelm called “Blood on the Ice.” It’s one of those quests that really stands out because it’s a murder mystery in the midst of a game filled with dragons, shouts, and epic battles.

When you first enter Windhelm, you might come across a crime scene with guards investigating a recent murder. This is your introduction to the “Blood on the Ice” quest. As you delve deeper, you’ll be tasked with gathering clues, interrogating suspects, and piecing together the puzzle to uncover the identity of the Butcher.

The quest has multiple stages and can be a bit tricky at times, especially when deciding whom to trust. It’s a great change of pace from the usual “go here, fetch that, slay this” type of quests, offering players a chance to put on their detective hats and solve a chilling mystery.

So, if you’re in the mood for some sleuthing in the snowy city of Windhelm, “Blood on the Ice” is definitely a quest you won’t want to miss! Just remember to keep your wits about you; the Butcher is more cunning than you might think.

A Complete Walkthrough of The Blood on the Ice Quest

“Blood on the Ice” is one of the more intriguing quests in Skyrim, and it can be a bit complex. Here’s a step-by-step walkthrough to guide you through:

1. Starting the Quest:

  • The quest typically starts when you first enter Windhelm, either by the main gate, docks, or fast traveling. You’ll encounter a crime scene in the Stone Quarter. A woman named Susanna has been murdered.
  • If you don’t get the quest immediately, don’t worry. Sometimes it takes a few visits to Windhelm or progressing further in the main storyline.

2. Examine the Crime Scene:

  • Approach the crime scene and speak to the guard. He’ll direct you to Jorleif, the steward in the Palace of the Kings.
  • Talk to Jorleif, and he’ll give you permission to aid in the investigation.

3. Gather Clues:

  • Head back to the crime scene and talk to the three witnesses: Calixto, Helgird, and Silda.
  • Visit Helgird in the Hall of the Dead. She’ll provide information about the state of Susanna’s body.

4. Visit Hjerim:

  • Jorleif will give you the key to Hjerim, the supposed murderer’s home.
  • Inside Hjerim, you’ll find:
    • Butcher’s Journal #1: On a wardrobe.
    • Strange Amulet: On a shelf near the wardrobe. (Remember this; it’s important!)
    • Beware the Butcher!: Flyers scattered around.
    • Butcher’s Journal #2: In a chest in the master bedroom.
  • Investigate the altar in the living room. It has bones, embalming tools, and more.

5. Follow the Clues:

  • Show the Strange Amulet to Calixto at Calixto’s House of Curiosities. He’ll offer to buy it for 500 gold. (Tip: Don’t sell it!)
  • Visit Viola Giordano. She’ll tell you about the flyers and her suspicions about Wuunferth the Unliving.

6. Accuse Wuunferth:

  • Head to the Palace of the Kings and accuse Wuunferth of being the Butcher. He’ll be imprisoned.

7. A Twist in the Tale:

  • After a few days, another murder will occur, indicating that Wuunferth was not the real killer.
  • Visit Wuunferth in his cell. He’ll explain his innocence and provide a lead: the real murderer will strike again at the Stone Quarter.

8. Catch the Butcher:

  • At night, patrol the Stone Quarter. You’ll eventually witness Calixto attempting to murder Arivanya.
  • Confront and defeat Calixto.

9. Conclusion:

  • Return to Jorleif or Wuunferth to report your success. Wuunferth will be released, and you’ll be rewarded.

Optional Steps:

  • If you sold the Strange Amulet to Calixto, you can buy it back and take it to Wuunferth. He’ll identify it as the Necromancer’s Amulet, a powerful artifact.

And there you have it! The mystery of the Butcher of Windhelm is solved. Remember, this quest can be a bit buggy at times, so it might not always play out exactly as described. Saving often and keeping multiple save files is always a good idea when tackling “Blood on the Ice.” Happy sleuthing!

Pros and Cons of Completing This Quest

“Blood on the Ice” is a unique quest in Skyrim that offers a departure from the usual combat-heavy adventures. Like any quest, it has its pros and cons:


  1. Unique Experience: It’s one of the few detective-style quests in Skyrim, offering a change of pace from the usual dungeon delving and dragon fighting.
  2. Hjerim Ownership: Completing the quest allows you to purchase the Hjerim house in Windhelm. Hjerim is one of the larger homes available to players and has several customization options.
  3. Necromancer’s Amulet: If you didn’t sell the Strange Amulet to Calixto, you can later identify it as the Necromancer’s Amulet. It’s a powerful artifact that boosts your Magicka, makes Conjuration spells cost less, and decreases your health regeneration.
  4. Justice and Closure: You bring justice to the victims of the Butcher and provide closure to the city of Windhelm, which has been living in fear.
  5. Rewards: Apart from the satisfaction of solving the mystery, you’ll also receive some gold as a reward.


  1. Buggy Quest: “Blood on the Ice” is notorious for being one of the buggier quests in Skyrim. Players might encounter issues that prevent them from starting or completing the quest.
  2. Moral Dilemma: Some players might feel bad about wrongfully accusing Wuunferth and having him imprisoned, even if it’s temporary.
  3. Missed Opportunity with Calixto: If you sell the Strange Amulet to Calixto early on, you miss out on obtaining the Necromancer’s Amulet, a valuable artifact.
  4. Time-Consuming: The quest requires a lot of running around Windhelm, speaking to various NPCs, and waiting for specific times to catch the Butcher in action.
  5. Potential for Another Murder: If you don’t catch the Butcher quickly after Wuunferth’s imprisonment, another innocent NPC might get killed.

In conclusion, while “Blood on the Ice” offers a unique experience and valuable rewards, it also comes with its own set of challenges and potential pitfalls. Whether or not to undertake it depends on your interest in solving mysteries and your patience for dealing with potential bugs.

The Butcher of Skyrim: An Opinion

Ah, “Blood on the Ice”! When I think about my adventures in Skyrim, this quest always stands out. It’s not every day you get to play detective in a world filled with dragons and Daedric Princes. The eerie atmosphere of Windhelm, combined with the chilling murders, created a suspenseful backdrop that was a refreshing change from the usual hack-and-slash quests.

The Butcher himself? What a twist! I remember piecing together the clues, suspecting everyone from the Court Mage to random townsfolk. When the true identity of the Butcher was revealed, I was genuinely taken aback. It’s not often a game can surprise me like that.

However, I have to admit, the quest had its frustrations. The bugs and glitches were a bit of a downer. There were moments when I felt like shouting “Fus Ro Dah!” at my screen. And the moral dilemma of wrongfully accusing Wuunferth? That weighed on my conscience, even if it was just a game.

All in all, “Blood on the Ice” is a memorable quest, flaws and all. It’s a testament to Skyrim’s rich storytelling that, even amidst epic battles and world-altering events, a single murder mystery can leave such a lasting impression. Would I play it again? Absolutely. But this time, I’d keep a closer eye on Calixto from the start!

Final Words and Summary

Ah, fellow adventurers, as we wrap up our journey through the chilling streets of Windhelm, it’s clear that “Blood on the Ice” is more than just another quest—it’s a testament to the rich tapestry of stories that Skyrim weaves. From the eerie crime scenes to the shocking revelation of the Butcher’s identity, this questline offers a unique blend of suspense, intrigue, and moral dilemmas. Let’s recap our epic tale:

  • The mysterious “Butcher” of Windhelm and the intrigue surrounding him.
  • The unique detective-style gameplay of the “Blood on the Ice” quest.
  • The moral complexities of accusing the wrong person.
  • The rewards and pitfalls of navigating this intricate quest.
  • The significance of the Necromancer’s Amulet and its role in the story.
  • The importance of guides like this in navigating the vast world of Skyrim.

So, Dragonborn, are you ready to uncover more secrets of Tamriel? Dive into the “What Next?” section and continue your quest for knowledge!

What Next?

I always believe that every tale should leave you with something actionable, a way to channel that newfound knowledge into your next adventure. Here’s what you can do next:

  • Revisit Windhelm: Armed with this guide, replay the quest and see if you notice any new details.
  • Explore Other Mysteries: Skyrim is filled with hidden stories. Dive into another unsolved mystery or questline.
  • Engage with the Community: Share your experiences and insights on gaming forums or social media.
  • Write Your Own Guide: Got a unique perspective or tips on another quest? Share your wisdom!
  • Challenge Yourself: Try completing “Blood on the Ice” without any external help. Trust your instincts!


Nick Sinclair

Nick Sinclair, a gaming aficionado since the Commodore 64 era, studied Creative Computer Games Design in university before founding his own gaming company. Discovering a passion for content creation, Nick now helps gamers squeeze every drop of fun out of their favorite gaming hardware

Recent Posts